Design & Engineering Considerations
The dimensional tolerances achievable through photochemical etching are directly and predictably related to material thickness, with thinner materials capable of holding significantly tighter absolute tolerances than thicker materials. This relationship is not arbitrary but reflects fundamental aspects of how the chemical etching process works, particularly the interaction between etch depth and the lateral undercut that develops as a natural consequence of isotropic material removal. Understanding this thickness-to-tolerance relationship enables designers to select appropriate material gauges that balance functional requirements for strength and rigidity against the desire for tight dimensional control.
At the thin end of the spectrum, ultra-thin foils ranging from 0.001 to 0.010 inches (0.025 to 0.25mm) can maintain exceptionally tight tolerances as precise as ±0.001 inch on critical dimensions. As material thickness increases into the mid-range of 0.010 to 0.030 inches (0.25 to 0.75mm), tolerances naturally expand to approximately ±0.001 to ±0.003 inches depending on the specific thickness. At the upper end of the standard photochemical etching range, materials from 0.030 to 0.060 inches (0.75 to 1.5mm) typically hold tolerances of ±0.003 to ±0.006 inches. The general guideline that tolerances approximate ±10% of material thickness provides a reliable planning tool across the entire thickness spectrum.
The physical mechanisms underlying this thickness-to-tolerance relationship stem from the isotropic nature of chemical etching and the undercut that develops as etchant dissolves material laterally beneath the photoresist mask while simultaneously penetrating vertically through the thickness. The amount of undercut is directly proportional to the depth etched, typically following etch factor ratios of 1:1 to 3:1 that relate vertical depth to horizontal undercut distance.
In double-sided etching, the standard approach where material is etched from both top and bottom surfaces simultaneously, each surface must etch approximately halfway through the total thickness before the opposing etch fronts meet and breakthrough occurs. For thin materials, this means relatively shallow etching from each side with correspondingly limited undercut. For thick materials, deeper etching from each surface produces proportionally greater undercut, consuming more of the original feature dimension and making absolute dimensional control more challenging.
Consider the practical difference between thin and thick materials. When etching 0.002 inch foil from both sides with a 2:1 etch factor, each surface etches approximately 0.001 inch deep, producing only 0.0005 inch of undercut from each side for total lateral material removal of 0.001 inch. This minimal undercut can be precisely controlled through careful process timing and monitoring. In contrast, etching 0.040 inch material from both sides means each surface must penetrate 0.020 inches deep, creating 0.010 inch of undercut from each side with the same 2:1 etch factor, for total lateral removal of 0.020 inches. This much larger undercut accumulates over longer etching times, providing more opportunity for process variations to affect final dimensions.
Materials at the thin end of the thickness spectrum, from 0.001 to 0.005 inches, demonstrate the remarkable precision capabilities of photochemical etching. These gossamer foils, some barely thicker than household aluminum foil, can be etched with tolerances as tight as ±0.001 inch, rivaling the finest precision available in any metal fabrication technology. The minimal undercut that develops during the brief etching cycles required for such thin materials, combined with rapid etch response that allows precise timing control, enables this exceptional dimensional accuracy.
Applications leveraging this extreme precision include microelectronic lead frames where conductor spacing directly affects electrical performance and manufacturing yield. Precision encoder discs for measurement systems require accurate hole positioning and sizing to achieve specified resolution. Medical diagnostic components demand exact aperture dimensions that control optical or radiation beam characteristics. Filtration membranes need consistent pore sizing to achieve target particle retention specifications. In each case, the ability to hold ±0.001 inch tolerances in thin materials makes photochemical etching the enabling manufacturing technology.
The percentage tolerance represented by ±0.001 inch varies dramatically with thickness. For 0.002 inch material, ±0.001 inch represents a substantial ±50% tolerance, reflecting the challenges of controlling very small absolute dimensions. For 0.010 inch material, ±0.001 inch represents ±10%, a much tighter relative tolerance that becomes increasingly impressive as features grow larger than the minimum size relative to thickness.
As material thickness increases into the 0.010 to 0.030 inch range, tolerances naturally expand to maintain the approximate ±10% of thickness relationship. For 0.010 inch material, expect ±0.001 inch tolerance. At 0.015 inches, ±0.0015 inch represents typical achievable accuracy. For 0.020 inch material, ±0.002 inch tolerance applies, while 0.030 inch material typically holds ±0.003 inch.
These mid-range tolerances still represent excellent precision by manufacturing standards, comparing favorably with stamping for complex features and matching or exceeding laser cutting without the thermal distortion and heat-affected zones that plague thermal processes. The reliability and repeatability of photochemical etching means these tolerances are maintained consistently part after part and lot after lot, without the tool wear and dimensional drift that affects mechanical processes.
Applications at these thickness levels include contact springs requiring precise dimensions to achieve specified contact force and deflection characteristics. Structural brackets combining lightweight design with adequate rigidity benefit from the dimensional consistency. Electronic chassis components with mounting holes, alignment features, and complex cutouts require the geometric complexity and tolerance control photochemical etching provides. Heat sink components with intricate fin patterns demand both the complexity and dimensional accuracy the process delivers.
At the upper end of the standard thickness range, from 0.030 to 0.060 inches, tolerances expand proportionally with the ±10% guideline yielding ±0.003 to ±0.006 inch expectations. These thicker gauges are selected when structural requirements, load bearing capacity, or rigidity demands dictate heavier material than thinner gauges provide. The tolerance relaxation compared to thin materials represents the necessary tradeoff for the increased strength and stiffness thick materials offer.
While ±0.006 inch may seem loose compared to the ±0.001 inch possible in thin foils, perspective matters. For many applications, ±0.006 inch provides entirely adequate dimensional control. Mounting brackets, structural reinforcements, heavy-duty heat sinks, and load-bearing components typically have feature sizes and functional tolerances that make ±0.006 inch acceptable or even generous. The percentage tolerance may actually be tighter than thin materials if features are appropriately sized relative to material thickness.
Designers can optimize tolerance performance by understanding the thickness relationship and making informed material selection decisions. When tight absolute tolerances on small features are critical, select the thinnest material that provides adequate strength and rigidity. If the application can function with 0.010 inch material instead of 0.020 inch, the achievable tolerance immediately improves from ±0.002 inch to ±0.001 inch.
Recognize that not all dimensions require the same tolerance. Critical functional dimensions like hole spacing for assembly alignment, aperture sizes that affect optical or fluid flow performance, or spring dimensions that control force characteristics deserve tight tolerances and should be explicitly called out on drawings. Non-critical dimensions like overall part size, large clearance holes, or decorative features may function perfectly well with looser tolerances that allow normal process variation without rejecting parts.
Feature size relative to material thickness also affects achievable tolerance. Larger features typically hold tighter percentage tolerances than features at the minimum size for the thickness. A 0.100 inch hole in 0.020 inch material might reliably hold ±0.001 inch, while a 0.020 inch hole in the same material might vary by ±0.002 inch because undercut consumes a much larger percentage of the nominal dimension.
The predictable relationship between material thickness and tolerance enables confident design decisions, reliable manufacturing specifications, and successful part production across the full range of photochemical etching capabilities from gossamer foils to substantial sheet stock.
4020 Jeffrey Blvd. | BUFFALO, NY 14219
P: (716) 821-9393 / (800) 875-1093
Website by Luminus
